All exam essays for American Board Courses are evaluated using this Rubric:
Click to Enlarge
. You will receive a score between 1 and 6. A score of 4 or higher is considered passing. Each score point has two downloadable sample responses.
A score of six indicates an outstanding response that is very effective at communicating its message to the specified audience. The response is well organized and contains a very clear introduction, body, and conclusion. It maintains a clear flow of ideas and a sustained focus with a clearly evident purpose. The writer fully develops and elaborates ideas. The writer demonstrates mastery of grammar and mechanics (e.g., spelling and punctuation) and uses great variety and complexity in sentence structure. Word choice is precise and diverse, and a strong vocabulary is evident.
A score of five indicates a very good response that effectively communicates a message to the specified audience. The writer maintains a focused, well-organized presentation that contains a coherent introduction, body, and conclusion. The focus is clear and the flow of ideas maintains that focus. The writer exhibits strong control in the development of ideas and provides details in support of those ideas. Sentence structure is varied and word choice and vocabulary are appropriate to the message. There is strong control of grammar and of mechanics such as spelling and punctuation.
A score of four indicates an adequate response that competently communicates a message to the specified audience. Though the purpose and focus of the response may be clear, the development of ideas may not be fully realized. The writer’s organization of ideas is evident but may lack specificity, be incomplete or not developed in effective sequence. Sentence structure is adequate, although there may be some minor errors in word choice and vocabulary. There is evidence of control in grammar and mechanics, though minor errors in the use of conventions may be present.
A score of three indicates a limited response that only partially communicates a message to the specified audience. The purpose and central idea are only partially evident and focus may wander from the central idea. An introduction and a body may be present, but a conclusion may be missing. Though there may be some limited development of ideas, they may not be fully supported with details. Although the response may exhibit limited control in grammar and mechanics, there may be distracting errors in spelling, punctuation, the use of grammatical conventions, a lack of precision in word choice and limited vocabulary.
A score of two indicates a seriously flawed response that does not effectively communicate a message to the specified audience. There is often no clear statement of a main idea or point of view and the writer’s efforts to present supporting detail are weak or confused. Any organization that exists fails to present an effective sequence of ideas, and there is little or no evidence of an introduction, body, or conclusion. There are many errors in mechanical conventions of usage, sentence structure, grammar, spelling, and punctuation, and the writer’s vocabulary is limited.
A score of one indicates a fundamentally deficient response that shows little evidence of mastery of organization, development, sentence structure, and mechanics.